data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4959d/4959d6fd8f47c4184fda6139997307432b8b7e69" alt="Screen capture of opening scene of Final Fantasy X"
(Music from Final Fantasy X Soundtrack)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/086e5/086e504932da18f6a3f81f6511cf223fcdd4cc33" alt="FFX temple statues"
When a summoner dies during the defeat of Sin, a statue of them is added to each of the temples. Link to image source:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1f3bf/1f3bf0893791a1a8000f3fd6d0e5d67b782cb33f" alt="St. Peter or Paul, Bath Abbey"
In 2007, I traveled with a church group to England to study Lewis & Tolkien (and see a few sights). One day we went to Bath. By the time that I had finished the tour of the Roman baths, the Abbey had already closed. Since some of us had to wait for people to come out of the Abbey, we wandered around out front. At some point I looked up and saw this statue. I didn't particularly care that he was there to look down on/judge me, so I took a picture. Unfortunately, the picture is blurry.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ea374/ea374b9b73161fa77db05c4afbd5729af5bdb4a7" alt="26 Martyrs Monument-Nagasaki, Japan"
"After the Atomic Bomb destroyed the whole city of Nagasaki, in 1956 the Martyrs Site was made into a park, and stood as a symbol of endurance and the hope of the citizens of rising again after the disaster. In 1962, the famous Japanese sculptor Yasutake Funakoshi erected in this place the beautiful Monument of the 26 Martyrs. Also was decided to build a Museum for perpetual memory of the Martyrs here, and the building, together with the Shrine, was entrusted to the [...] Architect Kenji Imai"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/086e5/086e504932da18f6a3f81f6511cf223fcdd4cc33" alt="FFX temple statues"
When a summoner dies during the defeat of Sin, a statue of them is added to each of the temples. Link to image source:
History
Written in Stone
Drip. Drip. Tears and Time.
Lonely souls wither in silence
Loud forgotten cries
For this discourse, the first step is to identify the community from which to pull a story from. Considering my site, and my burning question, I had a few communities I could choose from. I could choose:
-
The remix/mashup community
-
The writing community
-
My church/the Christian community
-
The video gaming community
-
The Japanese community (Final Fantasy X was made in Japan)
-
The Shibuya community, where SquareEnix's home office is located
-
The community of Spira
Of these communities, the church community seemed the most possible as it is the community that I most identified with and it was associated with the problem that inspired my burning question. However, the only person/event that I could think to do this discourse on was Jesus/the crucifixion, which I did not want to do. Knowing this, I started thinking about figures and events in church art because, through art, many of the stories a community tells about itself are perserved. As I did, I had Final Fantasy X in the back of my mind. In Final Fantasy X, the event that was most celebrated was the beginning of The Calm (the time period where Sin disappeared from the world while it rebuilt itself). Equally celebrated were the summoners who brought The Calm. Statues of the summoners could be found in every known temple, where the townspeople and travelers often visited. The first image in the gallery for this discourse is of the inside of a temple where the statues of those who brought the calm are on prominent display. Because the image is dark, I outlined and captioned each statue.
Because this game drew much inspiration from Catholicism, these statues reminded me of the statues in cathedrals. In particular, it reminded me of a photo I took of one statue over the doorway to Bath Abbey in England, the second image in this gallery. I think the statue was of Saint Peter, but I'm not sure. I didn't see how doing this discourse about St. Peter was going to connect to the rest of the mystory, but the image from England inspired me to look at Japan's sculptures, as Final Fantasy X originated in Japan. Other than the Buddha statues that appeared in an Google Image search, I didn't find very much that I felt like I could pull from. Then I was reminded of a scene from the anime, Rurouni Kenshin. In the arc that might officially be called the Christian arc (but I have not found proof of this) there is a scene that is particularly striking to me. In episode 72, the audience learns about the history of the antagonist, and in the scene where the antagonist is fleeing Japan, he looks up to see a grove of crucifixes on a cliff. The sheer number of crosses was a punctum for me as it suggested a time of persecution that I was surprised to have never heard of before. This led me to do some further research, and then I came across the 26 martyrs.
To Zanarkand
History Discourse
[Document] an exemplary story from your community, that is a story about a person or event that your community identifies with and tells about itself in its celebrations, festivals, naming practices (of streets, buildings, parks, memorials).
- Ulmer, Internet Invention, 191
A Google Map that approximately traces the journey of the martyrs and shows its relation to SquareEnix's office location and FFX's scenario writer's birthplace:
https://mapsengine.google.com/map/edit?mid=zfqHLgBmFmgU.kZA67x6rRV0k
References
26martyrs.com. 26martyrs.com. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://www.26martyrs.com/
BUSINESS LOCATIONS AND SUBSIDIARIES | SQUARE ENIX. BUSINESS LOCATIONS AND SUBSIDIARIES | SQUARE ENIX. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://www.jp.square-enix.com/company/en/locations/
Conover, C. B. (2008). A saint in the empire: Mexico city's san felipe de jesus, 1597--1820. (Order No. 3344191, The University of Texas at Austin). ProQuest Dissertations and Theses, , 387. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/288219514?accountid=6167. (288219514).
Ferrero, Mario. (Aug. 2002). Competition for sainthood and the millennial church. Wiley Online Library. Kyklos. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1467-6435.00190/pdf
Frequently asked questions regarding 4 STEPS TO SAINTHOOD. Frequently Asked Questions: Three Steps to Sainthood. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://www.catholicdoors.com/faq/qu221.htm
George, Katherine, and Charles H. George. Roman catholic sainthood and social status a statistical and analytical study. JSTOR. The Journal of Religion. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://www.jstor.org/stable/1200595
Guimarães, Atila S. and Plinio Correa De Oliveira. The martyrs of Japan - February 5. Tradition in Action. Retrieved on Mar. 17, 2014 from http://www.traditioninaction.org/SOD/j211sd_MartyrsJapan_02_05.html
Hickman, Kennedy. "Tokugawa Shogunate: Shimabara Rebellion." About.com Military History.Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://militaryhistory.about.com/od/battleswars16011800/p/shimabara.htm
Kazui, Tashiro, and Susan Downing Videen. Foreign relations during the edo period: Sakoku reexamined. JSTOR. Journal of Japanese Studies. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://www.jstor.org/stable/132341
Kazushige Nojima. Final Fantasy Wiki. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://finalfantasy.wikia.com/wiki/Kazushige_Nojima
Kirishitan. (Aug. 3, 2014) Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirishitan
List of the 26 Martyrs of Japan in Nishizaka, Nagasaki. List 26 Martyrs English. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://210.136.236.116/MartyrsHP/ListEngl.html
Ren Suzugamori. (Aug. 30, 2012). Rurouni Kenshin episode 72. YouTube. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HlkNxRfWI9A
Saint. Oxford English Dictionary. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/169847?rskey=yf3b5H&result=1&isAdvanced=false#eid
Schneider, Siegfried. (1980). The 26 martyrs of Japan. Chuo Press. 1980. p. 16
Shibata, Chizuo. The concept of life and death in christian martyrdom in Japan. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://www.lsfmissiology.org/Essays/ShibataConceptofLifeandDeathinChristianMartyrdominJapan.pdf
Ulmer, Gregory L. Internet Invention: From Literacy to Electracy. New York: Longman, 2003. Print.
Woodward, Kenneth L. (1996). Making Saints: How The Catholic Church Determines Who Becomes A Saint, Who Doesn't, And Why. Google Books. Simon and Schuster. Retrieved on Mar. 10, 2014 from http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=JImU5EZo7O8C&oi=fnd&pg=PR11&dq=criteria+for+catholic+sainthood&ots=ow2BtkG1Kh&sig=pH8epea1fqxfTf4NqKsg1fGJZXw#v=onepage&q&f=false
Yuki, Diego R., and Francis Britto. The martyrs' hill Nagasaki 1. February 5, 1597. All About Francis Xavier. Retrieved on Mar. 17, 2014 from http://pweb.cc.sophia.ac.jp/britto/xavier/yuki/yukidiego01.pdf
26 Martyrs and Sainthood
The story of the 26 martyrs began near the end of the Azuchi-Momoyama or Shokuho period, a time in which Japan was being reunified by Toyotomi Hideyoshi after a Civil War. During this time, Christianity had taken root in Japan and approximately 400,000 Japanese had converted, according to Chizuo Shibata (p. 11). Shibata also said that a number of these conversions were inspired by visions of conquest. Because the missionaries were debating about whether or not Japan should be conquered and colonized before evangelized, a number of the Japanese lords who heard these debates converted in order to gain weapons that they would then use to overpower the neighboring lords (Shibata, p.12). In addition to the issues that this caused, Japan had to also struggle with the conflicts being played out between the "competing" factions of Catholicism (Jesuit, Franciscans, Dominicans) (Shibata, p. 12). Eventually, Toyotomi Hideyoshi became suspicious of the Christians and issued a decree that was meant to expel the missionaries. However, this decree had little effect as the decree was not properly enforced. After some years, when he became more worried about the Christian influence, he decreed an order that would ultimately cause the 26 martyrs to be killed. ("Kirishitan;" Shibata, p. 15)
In early 1597,
160 Christians were arrested, but an official, Mitsumari Ishida, a sympathizer of the Christians, had reduced the number of apprehended persons down to 24. Most of them were arrested in Kyoto, and they had part of their ears cut off and were forced to parade through the streets of Kyoto as a warning to the people of that city. Then they were brought to Sakai, a commercial seaport. From there, they were forced to travel on foot all the way down to Nagasaki, almost 500 miles in bitter winter weather. The forced march took more than a month. En route, two others joined them of their own will. So all together there were 26 believers, including 6 foreign missionaries. They were executed immediately when they arrived in Nagasaki, on Nishisaka, a hill overlooking the town. Their dead bodies were left on the crosses for many days. (Shibata, p. 15)
The fourth image in the gallery maps the journey made by the 26 from Kyoto to Nagasaki. The 26 were taken to Nagasaki, because it was a large port city where the majority of foreigners conducted trades with the Japanese and where the majority of missionaries entered Japan.
In early February, the 26 arrived, and were eager to see the crosses waiting for them, as is recounted in Diego Yuki's "Martyr's HIll" and the "26 Martyrs' Story" link on the left sidebar of http://www.26martyrs.com/.
The martyrs know that each has his own cross, because they have been made to measure. Fr. Ganzalo, the first to arrive, goes straight to one of the crosses: "Is this mine?" It is not. Taken to another cross, he kneels down and embraces it. The others, one after another, start doing the same. "That was quite a sight, the way Br. Philip was embracing his cross..., " comments one of the witnesses. ("26martyrs.com"; Yuki, p. 3)
Because 26martyrs.com and Yuki do not specifically indicate where they got this comment by the witnesses, I tried to find a source that did. Instead, I found another version of this same scene with a different martyr that had been recounted by Atila Guimarães, Plinio Correa De Oliveira, and Siegfried Schneider:
On the way up the hill, a man tempted the youngest boy Louis Ibaragi, age 12, to renounce his faith. He would not yield but eagerly asked, “Where is my cross?” When they pointed out the smallest one to him, he immediately embraced it and held on to it as a child clings to his toy. (Guimarães & Correa De Oliveira; Schneider)
If the former version is true and each of the martyrs embraced their cross, then the latter could also be true, but in both cases, I did not find the original source for these stories. It is possible that each of these segments came from each martyr's beatification materials, but, as Cornelius Conover (2008) said in his dissertation, beatification materials are not reliable, "Noting the stock phrases and rigid procedures of saintly processes, studies have concluded that clergymen manipulated testimony" (p.74). Despite their lack of reliability, these segments are still part of the story that the church tells about itself, which means that in either case, at least some of the martyrs eagerly greeted their crosses and eventual death. As the story on 26martyrs.com continues, it says that these men were not nailed to their crosses, but held their by chains and were given props to sit on. One of the martyrs ended up being too short for his cross, and had to be tied around the chest. Another martyr's prop was too low, so when his strength was failing him, he began to suffocate from the ring around his neck. The executioners then crossed two lances in his chest, killing him. This lancing technique was used on the other martyrs as well, and if the initial lancing somehow didn't kill the martyr, a thrust to the neck was added. When all were dead (or thought to be dead) the crowd pushed through the guards and clamored for every piece of potential relic that they could get their hands on. Then the bodies were left to hang for at least 37 days, according to Fr. Francis Calderon. ("26martyrs.com")
Soon after the 26 were martyred, Toyotomi Hideyoshi died, and Tokugawa Ieyasu became the next leader, which marked the beginning of the Tokugawa era and the Edo period. During this time, Christian persecution continued, and an estimated 40,000 Christians were killed as a result (Shibata, p. 16). Of these, at least 650 were killed on Nishisaka Hill ("26martyrs.com"). In the mid 1600's, Tokugawa Iemitsu, Ieyasu's grandson and successor, issued the famous edicts that would effectively seclude Japan. Some have blamed this seclusion on the conflicting relations with the Christian nations, but Kazui and Videen suggest that this one-to-one correalation cannot be made. Tashiro Kazui and Susan Downing Videen, in their article, "Foreign Relations during the Edo Period: Sakoku Reexamined," said that it was commonly thought that, during this time, the continued trade with the Chinese and Dutch in Nagasaki was the only window to the rest of the world that Japan maintained. However, Kazui and Videen go on to say that Japan also maintained relations with the Korea and Ryukyu Islands, which therefore means that, "It is clear, then, that we must not limit our examination of foreign relations during this period to the role of Christianity and to Nagasaki and its relationship with Europe" (Kazui & Videen, p. 284-285).
When the borders of Japan were reopened, church officials arrived to research the 26 martyrs' eligibility for sainthood. In 1862, they were all canonized ("List of 26 Martyrs"). This is important, because this possibility of sainthood is likely what motivated many, including the 26, to become martyrs. Saints are considered to be role models, they "represent the highest human realization of the religious profession in question" (George, 85). In the Catholic tradition, it is also traditionally thought that saints have higher status in heaven (George, 85; "Saint"). According to Ferrero (2002) and Woodward (1996), around the time that the martyrs were killed, sainthood was roughly defined. According to the latter source, sainthood was then connected to whether or not a popular cult had formed around the saint candidate(s) (p. 50). Later, the criteria could be boiled down to doctrinal orthodoxy, miracles, heroic virtue, and martyrdom (Ferrero, 2002, p. 341). Martyrdom is initially defined as one who willingly dies "for the faith at the hands of a tyrant who is opposed to the faith" (Woodward, 1996, p.129). However, Woodard says that ideally the church wanted the martyr to be one whose witnessing provokes the tyrant. According to the story, the 26 martyrs fell into the latter category.
"Frequently Asked Question Regarding 4 STEPS TO SAINTHOOD" provides a simplified description of the current process of determining sainthood. While I have yet to find proof, I suspect that the process was much the same in 1862 as it is today. According to Woodward (1996), achieving sainthood meant a few things. It meant that the church would identify the saint from time to time and encourage the populace to emulate the saint's life (p. 13, 51), that the saint's life would be used by the church to tell stories about itself (p. 13), and that a feast day for celebrating the saint would be added to the church calendar (p. 51). For the 26 martyrs it meant that (at the very least) Japan would one day build a museum and a shrine in their honor. Both structures were built after the atomic bomb and were opened in 1956 (26martyrs.com). By the look of the website, it seems that the museum, while featuring the 26 martyrs, memorializes all of the Christians who died on Nishisaka Hill during the Edo period. The relief on the side of the museum is the last image in this discourse's gallery.
Final Fantasy X Connection
There is definitely a connection between the Catholic's saints and Final Fantasy X's high summoners, but the specific connection between the 26 martyrs and Final Fantasy X is not as easily found. Using the zoom feature on the two maps below, you can see that there isn't a location based connection. This is even more the case when you look at the map linked below these two maps which includes a marker at the birthplace of Final Fantasy X's scenario writer. The scenario writer, Kazushige Nojima, was born in Sapporo, which is on Hokkaido Island--the northernmost of the main islands ("Kazushige Nojima"). SquareEnix's office is located in Shibuya, Tokyo, which is on Honshu Island--the largest of main islands ("BUSINESS LOCATIONS"). And the hill where the 26 martyrs were killed and where the museum was built is in Nagasaki, which is on the North Western side of Kyushu Island--the southernmost of the main islands. While these locations do not suggest any connection between Final Fantasy X and the 26 martyrs, Tokyo's connection to Kyoto might suggest something. If you remember, Kyoto was the place where 24 of the 26 martyrs were arrested. Back during that time period, Kyoto was the capital of Japan instead of Tokyo. When the capital of Japan moved to Tokyo, I doubt that anything related to the 26 martyrs moved with it, but there is still a chance.
Despite my ability to find where the martyrs story may have influenced Final Fantasy X, there are five connections between the story and the game that I've been able to make. The first is the amount of celebration the martyrs and Yunalesca share. Compared to the other high summoners in Final Fantasy X, Yunalesca, the first high summoner, is celebrated the most. In the temple, her statue is the largest of the high summoner statues. Likewise, the 26 martyrs were the first Christian martyrs of Japan and have the most recognition at the museum. The 26 martyrs also appear among the top results in internet searches for Japanese persecution of Christians. The other top internet result was the Shimabara rebellion. The Shimabara Rebellion started forty years after the 26's martyrdom and has been linked to Christian persecution, but was not expressly caused by the religious persecution (Hickman). The Shimabara Rebellion, which is sometimes called the "peasant revolt," was primarily caused by heavy taxation. However, because much of the population being taxed were Christians and because this rebellion influenced the decision to seclude Japan, the rebellion has been connected to Christian persecution. (Hickman)
While I had not heard of the 26 martyrs prior to this study, I had heard of the Shimabara Rebellion (though I had not been familiar with its connection to Christian persecution). This was probaly partially because the rebellion had a larger and longer lasting effect on Japan. This rebellion's large scale and loose connection to Christian persecution led me to consider Yunalesca's husband in Final Fantasy X. If you read the captions on the first image in the my discourse gallery, you may have noticed that Yunalesca's husband was the only non-summoner with a statue in the temple. As the people in Final Fantasy X credit the summoner with the defeat of Sin, the vital role that Yunalesca's husband played in the initial defeat of Sin is considered a by-product of his wife's chosen occupation. This is much like the way that the Shimabara Rebellion played an important role in the Japanese relationship with Christianity, but was not the result of Christian persecution. Another interesting thing to note about the statue of Yunalesca's husband is that, while the statues of Yunalesca and her husband are of matching scale, the build and clothing of Yunalesca's husband makes his statue appear more massive than Yunalesca's. This is similar to how the Shimabara Rebellion has had a larger impact on Japan compared to the 26 martyrs.
While I said before that the rebellion's impact is part of the reason that I had previously heard of the rebellion but not the martyrdom, Shibata and the 26 Martrys Museum website suggest another reason. Both said that the story of the 26 martyrs has been wrongfully left out of most history books. I'm not sure which history books they want this story to be included (English or Japanese; general history or specialized history), but as I tried to verify the eagerness with which the martyrs greeted their crosses, I was able to get some sense for the need. Many of the sources I found in that search would only mention the 26 martyrs and then would focus on the political and/or economic impact the Christians and/or martyrdoms were having on Japan. As all of these sources were written in English, the fact that most sources only mentioned the 26 didn't bother me because it told the reader who was not concerned with the details of religious landscape of that time the meat of what they needed to know in order to understand the political and economic landscapes. Also, by mentioning the martyrdom, enough of the story is revealed so that the reader who is interested in the religious landscape will know what they can do more research about. However, because I was looking for information about the 26 martyrs, it is possible that I did not read some of the more commonly used history books about Japan.
Because many history books do not detail the story of the 26's martyrdom, I'm reminded of how the details behind Yunalesca, Yevon, Sin, and the acquisition of the final monster needed to bring The Calm are also left out in the story that the world of Final Fantasy X tells about itself. In Final Fantasy X, these details were purposefully left out in order to maintain tradition and hide hypocrisy. I can't say with certainty that the reason behind the missing details in the 26 martyr's story was to make Japan's reputation appear less tarnished, but by leaving out these details this effect could be achieved.
Before I discuss the remaining connections, let me first discuss the punctums I experienced during my exploration of this story.
Mystory Connection
To determine how this relates to the rest of the mystory, I should first delve deeper into the punctum of this history. The initial punctums that led me to explore the story of the 26 martyrs were that of having never heard about the 26 martyrs and of only being vaguely aware of Christian persecution in Japan. However, within the story, was another punctum. The detail that led me to this puntum was the fact that the 160 captured Christians had been whittled down to 24 only to have two more Christians volunteer to join the condemned. As I read the story on the museum website, I found that the martyrs made me angry (punctum). While these martyrs were undoubtedly brave and strong and their deaths had an impact in the community, I did not feel that their deaths, while not meaningless, were meaningful enough. Because the number of condemned Christians had been reduced to 24, it meant that the 24 had a way of avoiding their death, but they chose not to. No source that I've encountered so far has indicated that the 136 survivors had to perform blasphemous acts in order to be released, so the choice of the 24 to stay did not seem particularly noble. However, because their choice to stay allowed 136 to be spared, their deaths can indeed be considered noble. This cannot be said of the two who volunteered. Between the two volunteer martyrs, the portrayal of the 26 martyrs' deaths, and the fact that that the church had been distributing guidebooks to "mold [the Christian's] faith life outlook on life and death" (Shibata, p.17), it is particularly hard for me to believe that these martyrs were motivated to die for less than selfish reasons. Martyrdom is one of the qualifications of sainthood, and sainthood is one of the highest statuses within the Catholic church. As said before, it is also traditionally thought that saints have higher status in heaven (George, 85; "Saint"). And when considering that the status of sainthood also meant that the church would identify the saint from time to time and encourage the populace to emulate the saint's life (Woodward, 1996, p. 13, 51), that the saint's life would be used by the church to tell stories about itself (Woodward, 1996, p. 13), that a feast day for celebrating the saint would be added to the church calendar (Woodward, 1996, p. 51), and that there home country had another saint to help prove whether or not the country had divine favor (Connover, 2008, p. vii), it seems more and more likely that the martyrs were motivated to die by the promise of higher status instead of community impact. Because martyrs are supposed to emulate Christ's sacrifice (Christ died to save his people, not so that he could sit next to God), the implied selfishness of these martyrs (particularly of the two who volunteered) ruins much of the story. Due to the fact that much of their motivation came from instructions being distributed by the church, this story has made me very angry at the church.
To briefly return to the Final Fantasy X connections, this anger I felt toward the church is similar to the anger that Yuna and Tidus felt when it was revealed that [spoiler] the summoner's death had no hope of truly defeating Sin. Additionally, the martyrs are like the summoners in that they willingly gave their lives based on teachings that the church distributed. The fayth are even more like these martyrs in that the martyrs were all deemed saints, and like saints, the fayth perform miracles (by creating aeons) and intercede to Yevon/God when called upon in the battle with Sin.[/spoiler]